Hello dear
Welcome to Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse
Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse, nestled in Warwick, NY, invites diners on a culinary journey that celebrates the art of Italian and steakhouse cuisine. With a commitment to impeccable service and vibrant flavors, each meal becomes a memorable experience. Guests rave about the perfectly cooked steaks, like the Center Cut Filet, and house-made desserts that leave a lasting impression. The ambiance, beautifully renovated, enhances the dining adventure, ideal for romantic evenings or casual lunches. Highlights include delightful bread paired with flavorful oils and sides that elevate every meal. Prime 36 doesn’t just serve food; it crafts unforgettable memories that beckon patrons to return.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse
Welcome to Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse, a culinary gem situated at 36 Oakland Ave, Warwick, NY 10990. With a focus on enriching the dining experience, this restaurant seamlessly blends traditional Italian cuisine with the boldness of classic steakhouses, creating a perfect atmosphere for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings.
Having recently transformed the former Warwick Inn into a stunning dining space, Prime 36 has quickly become a beloved locale. The inviting ambiance, coupled with impeccable service, draws patrons from near and far. As Julieth M. highlighted in her glowing review, the staff, notably Ariella, ensures that every dining experience is memorable, making special moments like Valentine’s Day truly unforgettable.
The menu at Prime 36 is a celebration of flavor. Diners rave about the perfectly cooked steaks, like the Center Cut Filet, which promises an ideal medium-rare every time. For those seeking a seafood delight, the cod has garnered compliments for being equally exceptional. As Harvey T. noted, both the food and service are at a consistently high standard. The chefs put immense care into creating a menu that caters to every taste—a detail that does not go unnoticed.
- Start your meal with their sumptuous bread basket, served with delicious sun-dried tomato oil, as Christina S. enjoyed during her visit.
- The Chicken Francesca, enjoyed by Marcella A., is another standout dish, combining rich flavors that leave you satisfied and wanting more.
- Don’t miss the house-made tres leches cake, praised by customers as a heavenly finish to any meal.
Despite some quirks noted by visitors—such as the request for more seasoning on appetizers or sauces to complement the stellar steaks—Prime 36 continues to impress. The attention to detail is evident, especially in their side dishes, like the flavorful asparagus and creamy garlic mash, which greatly enhance the main courses.
If you are searching for a delightful dining experience in Warwick, make Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse your destination. With a commitment to quality meals and warm hospitality, it's a place you’ll want to return to again and again. Whether it’s a romantic dinner or a casual lunch with friends, Prime 36 welcomes you with open arms and delectable dishes that promise to please your palate.
For reservations or inquiries, reach them at (845) 986-3666. Come and discover what makes Prime 36 a cut above the rest!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Valentine's Day was made absolutely memorable here with impeccable service by Ariella. She made sure our dining experience was perfect for our romantic night. The food was marvelous. The steak was perfect! But just when we thought everything could not get any better, the tres leches cake made its appearance and it was heaven! Thank you Prime 36 and its staff for making our evening so special. We will be back very soon! ”
“ My friend and I came here for lunch. I absolutely love coming here. There food is always very delicious. I absolutely love their bread and along with their delicious sauce for the bread. This time around I decided to get the Chicken Francesca which was very delicious. I decided to get it with the potatoe croquet and the fresh vegetables. The service was amazing. The waiter gave us a lot of time to come back and wait until we decided to have what we want. What we also loved that we were able to sit there and talk and not get rushed out. I highly recommend coming here and checking it out. ”
“ Food and service were both excellent. Our server was sweet and knowledgeable. The cod and steak were cooked to perfection. The bar area is a great vibe. ”
“ Don't order the tomahawk steak! Lol it's $145 and full of fat! Don't get me wrong it was delicious but definitely not worth the price as it wasn't as big. Place is gorgeous, service was excellent. I would definitely go back as food was delicious. ”
“ Brand new place in Warwick NY (previously the location of The Warwick Inn), which recently opened after FULL (gorgeous) renovation. My husband and I came in here on a Friday night hoping for a table, and luckily they had one available, despite us not having a reservation! We ordered drinks, and were immediately given a bread basket with cheese/pickles/olives (LOVE that they do this - I think restaurants should do this more often). The bread was super fresh, and the sun dried tomato oil we were given was SUPER tasty - my only comment? Don't put it on my own bread plate - instead - give us a plate to share the oil so we can use our bread plates for ... bread. For appetizers, we started with the Smoked Nova Scotia Salmon and Tuna Tartar - honestly, both were tasty, the salmon wasn't over smoked and both dishes were fresh... but they both desperately needed seasoning (aka salt). Next, we each had the Center Cut Filet - mine was a perfect Medium Rare, and my husband's was also Medium Rare ... except he ordered his Rare. The steaks were seasoned perfectly and tasted delicious. Only issue? No sauces (chimichuri, bernaise, bordelaise, etc)... if you're a steakhouse, gimme alllllll the sauces. The sides though ... those were amazing. Garlic Mash was perfectly mashed - little lumps (love them!), and not too garlicky. Onion Rings were addictingly good - a thousand of those, please. Asparagus Parm - holy heck they were flavorful and cooked perfectly - not mushy at all. We didn't take part in any desserts, but I love that they're all made in-house. 4 Stars because: 1- give me a designated oil plate with bread 2- season the appetizers 3- sauces for the steak! and make them homemade! ”
